Filing bankruptcy automatically does a lot of things. It automatically stops creditor harassment, such as foreclosure and repossession, whether or not this harassment is warranted. Furthermore, bankruptcy automatically discharges many unsecured debts, such as credit cards and medical bills. Finally, bankruptcy automatically protects your house, car, and other assets. This list of assets could include your security clearance, as outlined below.
Some of bankruptcy’s automatic effects are not good. For example, filing bankruptcy automatically lowers your credit score. However, this effect is usually not as bad as people believe it is. Essentially, filing bankruptcy lowers your score from bad to worse. It does not move your score from good to awful.
Bankruptcy does not automatically affect your security clearance. The due process requirement in the Fourteenth Amendment demands separate notice and hearing. Since bankruptcy’s Automatic Stay technically bars these actions, debtors control key elements of this hearing. Furthermore, and perhaps more importantly, DoD Directive 5220.6 includes a roadmap which allows debtors to rebuff efforts to invalidate their security clearances.
Financial Problems, State Secrets, and Bankruptcy
Desperation and financial problems usually go hand-in-hand. Most people have Post Traumatic Stress Disorder-type symptoms in these situations. Since they are not thinking clearly, they often make poor decisions, and the downward spiral continues.
Sometimes, people get so desperate and are in such a PTSD fog that they sell state secrets to raise money. Basically, these individuals only see the short-term gain (money in their bank account) and do not see the long-term consequences (security clearance revocation, or perhaps something much worse). Such incidents are quite rare. But they have happened before, and they will happen again.
So, the DoD has a legitimate reason to be concerned when security clearance-holders experience financial problems.
Merely filing bankruptcy alleviates this concern, at least in most cases. As mentioned, creditors cannot take adverse action against bankruptcy debtors. Thus, a bankruptcy filing reduces a debtor’s stress level and stops the aforementioned downward spiral.
Some Specifics
The particular financial problem/security clearance concerns, which are listed in Guideline F, often have little if anything to do with bankruptcy debtors.
- Inability or Unwillingness to Pay Debts: This area of concern could affect a filing decision. Chapter 13 debtors are able to pay their debts, if they receive a fair payment plan. Furthermore, the mere fact that they filed Chapter 13 means they are willing to pay them, or at least willing to pay most of them.
- Deceptive Practices: The DoD believes, with some justification, that if illegal behavior, such as “embezzlement, employee theft, check fraud, income tax evasion, expense account fraud, filing deceptive loan statements, and other intentional financial breaches of trust” caused debt, people might act illegally to get out of debt. Bankruptcy debtors rarely, if ever, have issues in such areas. Almost all of them are honest yet unfortunate.
- Illegal Activity: Bankruptcy usually does not involve any deceptive practices, as outlined above. It definitely does not involve “gambling, drug abuse, alcoholism, or other issues of security concern.” Filing bankruptcy would probably not help these people anyway.
In contrast, the mitigating circumstances, which are also listed in Guideline F, often have everything to do with filing bankruptcy.
- Lack of Control: The listed examples (“loss of employment, a business downturn, unexpected medical emergency, or a death, divorce or separation”) almost mirror the list of reasons people file consumer bankruptcy. Medical bills are atop this list.
- Turning the Corner: Financial problems are not a security issue if “The person has received or is receiving counseling for the problem and there are clear indications that the problem is being resolved or is under control.” All bankruptcy petitioners receive debt counseling. Furthermore, the repayment plan and debt discharge address all or most debt problems.
- Honest Attempt: If “The individual initiated a good-faith effort to repay overdue creditors or otherwise resolve debts,” the DoD is not concerned about the person’s financial problems. This process is bankruptcy in a nutshell.
An Athens bankruptcy lawyer can use these observations to prevail at a security clearance revocation hearing, as outlined below.
Security Clearance Hearings
Revocation hearings vary significantly in different areas. But they all must meet some fundamental requirements. For example, the hearing officer must be neutral, the security clearance holder must have an opportunity to be heard, and the DoD has the burden of proof.
This hearing might not happen at all. Bankruptcy’s Automatic Stay applies in these cases. So, even if a hearing is pending, it must be cancelled. Furthermore, since the areas of concern and mitigating circumstances weigh so heavily in favor of bankruptcy petitioners, the DoD might abandon the matter as a lost cause.
If the hearing moves forward, which is unlikely, an Athens bankruptcy lawyer can usually arrange for a probated revocation or a similar outcome. If there are no further demerits for a few months, the DoD forgets the matter.
Please be aware that this article was written and published in conjunction with the help of Gorilla Webtactics,
Law Firm Marketing Agency, and does not contain legal advice. Please do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read in this article.
About the Author
Christopher Ross Morgan is a principal attorney in Morgan & Morgan, Attorneys at Law, P.C. He is an active member of several state and national bar associations. In addition to consumer bankruptcy, Chris focuses on workers’ compensation and disability matters. Click here to learn more.